Vlad,
Year might be in string format.
Can you try the below formula.
=FormatDate(ToDate(UserResponse("Enter Sysdate");"M/dd/yyyy HH:mm:ss a");"yyyy")
=[Net Commission Usd] Where([Year]=FormatDate(ToDate(UserResponse("Enter value(s) for Action Time");"M/dd/yyyy HH:mm:ss a");"yyyy"))
-Sri Harsha